TechFreedom

It's rare I get on a plane these days, but when I do, I count out the number of steps to the closest exit. Doesn't everyone? No I'm told. To be fair I also do it if I ever set foot inside the Metro Centre or any indoor shopping centre. I want to know where my exits are. Too much time spent guiding people in the hills and mountains I think, always thinking what could go wrong, and having an evacuation point. 

You may be thinking, I'm pretty sure this was the TechFreedom newsletter? Well yes it is. So what has any of that got to do with Tech Tom? Well, when it comes to technology, it's probably good to know what your exit points are and what your emergency plans are. Why? Well let's begin with this one from last week...

Microsoft 365 experiences a major global outage

Hard to miss this one really.

The Microsoft outage on 12 & 13 November was everywhere. Outlook, Teams and other services were disrupted. Across the world people were left staring at a blank screen. NHS organisations, councils, police forces, schools and businesses were affected. People everywhere unable to communicate, unable to function.

Microsoft have said the underlying cause was a bug introduced during an earlier network infrastructure upgrade, which was then triggered by a subsequent change. The result was a cascading technical failure of massive proportions. It wasn't a cyberattack (although the Optimizly supply chain attack the following week which took down half of the US banks is another dependency eye opener) No, this was the sort of technical problem that can happen in systems into which half the world is locked into. 

When so many organisations rely on the same company and the same infrastructure, a single failure can have consequences far beyond the company's own customers.

And no it's not us saying we told you so. Nope this time it's Cory Doctorow saying I told you so.

His argument is that the problem isn't simply technical reliability but more so that the concentration of power, the lack of meaningful alternatives, and the policies that have allowed technology companies to become so dominant are the real issues. 

There are practical questions here for everyone here too. Could your organisation function without Microsoft 365 for a day? How about a week? Do you have access to essential documents offline? Is your backup actually separate from the service you're backing up? Do you even know how to contact everyone without your usual email system? DO WE HAVE TO USE MICROSOFT?! Oh, sorry I got carried away there....

Read Cory Doctorow's response

Things from us

1. We're organising a Digital Sovereignty Unconference!

We've secured a small amount of seed funding to help us organise a Digital Sovereignty Unconference in Newcastle upon Tyne in 2027.

If you've not been to an unconference before, the idea is relatively simple. Rather than organisers deciding everything in advance, the people who turn up help shape the agenda. No panels (Doug has thoughts). More conversations, workshops, sharing experiences, working through questions and making connections. We plan to have some lightning talks to inspire and challenge and then be led by the people in the room. 

We want to bring together people working in technology, charities, community organisations, local government, research, education and beyond. People who are techy and people who don't necessarily consider themselves technologists at all.

We're particularly interested in how digital sovereignty relates to communities, places and organisations trying to make positive social change.

We're still shaping the event but we hope to have a venue announced next week and our first partner on board to help it happen. But we still need more, we need people who want to come, partners, ideas and support to make it happen.

Register your interest in the Digital Sovereignty Unconference

2. Some new writing about digital sovereignty

Obviously if we're going to doing an unconference about Digital Sovereignty we should probably have some opinions on it ourselves. At FIELD STATION, we've published Digital sovereignty is ours to shape.

One of the difficulties with the phrase digital sovereignty is that it can mean so many different things.

For some, it means keeping data within national borders. For others, it's about open-source software, owning infrastructure, having alternatives to dominant technology companies, or simply being able to make informed decisions. All of these matter I suppose. But what interests us is the question of sovereignty for whom, over what, and for what purpose.

Tom has also written Sovereignty isn't a place, exploring why simply moving services from an American cloud provider to a European one doesn't necessarily give you more meaningful control.

Where your data lives matters, of course, but so does ownership, contracts, capabilities, interoperability, the law, and whether you can actually leave a provider when you want to.

The distinction between where something is and who has power over it feels increasingly important.

3. Just Enough AI - do we really need more?

Doug has been in Bristol for a Just Enough AI event, co-hosted by Friends of the Earth and the University of Bristol's Centre for Sociodigital Futures.

He was one of the demonstrators on the day and presented some of the things we are working on. He did not one, but two sets of kick ass slides for the event (which you can find on the link below and honestly, I urge you to read them).

It starts with a question we rather like: how much AI do we actually need? Much of the current conversation around AI assumes that bigger and more powerful is better. More data, more computing power, more automation, more AI in everything. But what if we started with the problem instead?

Perhaps a smaller model could do what we need. Maybe something running locally is sufficient. And just possibly we don't need AI at all.

Choosing technology that's appropriate to our needs, rather than simply accepting whatever the market is selling, is a rather good expression of digital freedom.

Read FIELD STATION's Just Enough AI reflections

4. Can you help us fund a TechFreedom cohort?

We ran a pilot of the TechFreedom programme and learnt a great deal about what organisations need to develop their technological independence. It was well received, the feedback was great. But...

One thing became clear: while the need is there, many of the organisations that could benefit most don't necessarily have the resources to pay for a programme like this themselves.

So we're exploring a different approach.

We're looking for funders interested in supporting a cohort of charities, community groups or other social-purpose organisations through TechFreedom.

The idea is to give organisations the space, knowledge and practical support to understand their technological dependencies and make better choices.

So if you're a funder, know a funder, or work with a network of organisations who might benefit, please get in touch with Doug or Tom. We'd love to explore what might be possible.


Other things that caught our attention

1. The Sharing Shift - openness needs to be sustainable

Here's something we've been thinking about quite a bit. We're advocates for open knowledge, open data and open-source software. But who pays for all of this?

The Open Knowledge Foundation's Sharing Shift is exploring how we create sustainable digital commons in the age of AI.

That means thinking about the legal, technical and social arrangements that allow knowledge to be shared while ensuring the communities creating it continue to benefit.

Explore The Sharing Shift

2. Who's responsible when AI agents start doing things?

Who answers when an AI agent makes a mistake?

Is it the person who gave the instruction? The organisation using the system? The developer who built the agent? The company that supplied the model?

The article Who answers for the AI agents? explores some of these questions.

3. What does good open-source practice actually look like?

Digital Public Goods Alliance has created an Open Source Software Government Maturity Self-Assessment.

Although it's designed for government institutions, much of it is relevant to other organisations too. What's interesting is that it doesn't just ask whether you use open-source software but looks at governance, procurement, financing, technical capabilities and collaboration.

 


A few other interesting things

A handful of links we've saved recently that are worth exploring:

We Must Kill Windows For A Just Future

The name says it all really. Ditch Windows and move towards Linux. 

Who owns the North East's AI economy?

Doug asks an important question about who will own the infrastructure, capabilities and resulting value of the emerging AI economy in our region. A local perspective on a much bigger issue.

Manifestos, Fear, and ‘Loser Thinking’: Inside Proton’s AI Reckoning

Although it feels like an age ago, the whole Proton mess was less than 1 month ago. 

Introducing open-1b: the first model you don’t have to trust

"a public fingerprint of every step that produced the model, and a tool that lets anyone replay those steps on their own hardware" - pretty cool

European.Social - The European Movement For The Open Social Stack

Tiny Little Office

A cool little in browser office tool. 

And Finally

Friends The Society of Hopeful Technologists are launching SOON. Not quite soon enough for this newsletter but you can stay up to date by signing up to the newsletter

 

 

 

CC BY TechFreedom